Simanaitis Says

On cars, old, new and future; science & technology; vintage airplanes, computer flight simulation of them; Sherlockiana; our English language; travel; and other stuff


SHERLOCKIANS RECOGNIZE Irene (pronounced I-re-nee) Adler as “The Woman,” the most highly respected of her gender by Holmes. Another woman, perhaps lesser known, was a Sherlockian extraordinaire: Edith Meiser.

Like Irene, Edith was an American and an actress. What’s more, Edith’s love of Holmes brought his adventures to radio, starring William Gillette, America’s first Holmes, and later Basil Rathbone, the Benedict Cumberbatch of his era. Later still, Edith co-authored a Sherlock Holmes comic strip for newspapers.


Sherlock Holmes, Book 1: The World’s Greatest Detective Star in 6 Complete Illustrated Adventures. by Edith Meiser and Frank Giacoia, compiled and edited by Tom Mason.

In addition to her Sherlockian activities, Edith’s career included writing mystery novels; a radio serial for actress Helen Hayes; and a play, The Wooden O, about Shakespeare’s Globe Theatre. She performed on the radio with the Marx Brothers. And she was Mrs. Littlefield in two 1952 episodes of TV’s I Love Lucy.


Edith Meiser, 1898 – 1993, American actress, writer, Sherlockian extraordinaire. Image from Island Fling, 1951.

Edith was born in Detroit in 1898. Her education was anything but a Midwestern norm: After the Liggett School in Detroit, she studied at Kox Schule in Dresden, Germany, and the Ecole de la Cour de St. Pierre in Geneva, Switzerland, all this before attending Vassar College.

During her four years at Vassar, Edith got involved with the college drama society. After graduation she performed with the American Shakespeare Festival, The Theater Guild, Edward Albee’s vaudeville circuit, Jessie Bonstelle’s Summer Stock Company and in the late 1920s’ Garrick Gaieties revue.

Edith and her husband Thomas McKnight, both Sherlockians, tried to interest burgeoning radio networks in putting Holmes stories on the air. Reluctant at first (why would Holmes sell in America?), finally a broadcaster went along with the idea when Edith not only wrote the scripts and hired the players, but arranged the sponsor as well.

The first U.S. radio broadcast of Holmes came on October 20, 1930, with William Gillette starring in Edith’s radio adaptation of “The Adventure of the Speckled Band.” Gillette had brought Holmes to American stages in 1899 and to a U.S. film in 1916.


By 1930, William Gillette remained the prototypical Holmes. Edith later related that, after directing Gillette in the New York City radio broadcast, she worried about his getting to his estate in Deep River, Connecticut, near the Massachusetts border. No problem: Gillette, age 80, hopped on his motorcycle and motored home!

These radio shows continued until 1936 and were revived in the fall of 1939, encouraged by the success of Basil Rathbone’s film portrayal of Holmes in The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.


The Sherlockian saga make big time Hollywood, 1939.

The “Red” and “Blue” Networks of NBC broadcast Edith’s scripts for Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce from 1939 to 1942. (NBC Blue Network was split off by government edict; eventually it became ABC. The Red Network remained as NBC.)


In total, 220 episodes of Sherlock Holmes radio adventures were broadcast, of which 103 are available for download from

In 1942, the half-hour show moved over to the Mutual Radio Network. According to William Nadel, Baker Street Irregular member and radio historian, “… one of the conditions of continuing the show on the Mutual Network was that Edith would come up with ‘new adventures.’ This she did through the middle of 1944 and then picked it up again in 1947 through the summer of 1948.”

Her biography at notes “Meiser’s adaptations and original stories were praised by Conan Doyle’s family, and she steadfastly refused to add violence and sex to the stories to get bigger audiences.”

Edith became a celebrated figure among Sherlockians and was made an honorary member of the Baker Street Irregulars. For a brief stint in the 1950s, she ran a Holmes newspaper comic strip, devised jointly with Frank Giacoia, who went on later to co-author Marvel Comics’ Captain America.


At the same time, Edith had her acting career. Her 1993 obituary in The New York Times cites movie roles in The Middle of the Night, 1959, based on Dorothy Parker stories; It Grows on Trees, 1952; and Queen for a Day, 1951. Edith was also on the board of governors of Actors Equity and a chairwoman of the Equity Library Theater.


An Al Hirschfeld portrait: from left to right, Edith Meiser, Eve Arden and Vivian Vance. New York Tribune, December 1951.

The Edith Meiser Collection is part of Special Collections and Rare Books at the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis. Its 14 boxes and 12 volumes include manuscript material, carbon, ditto and mimeograph copies of stories regarding Sherlock Holmes.

Quite a career for kid who fell in love at age 11 with the world’s greatest consulting detective. ds

© Dennis Simanaitis,, 2016


  1. Halford Jones
    October 31, 2016

    Very interesting page and informative for SHERLOCK HOLMES fans and gives Edith Meisner full credit for her work on the fictional detective and there is always more to this than meets the eye.After listening to tapes and dvds on Holmes and hearing the audio comments on her, I decided to look up more information about here and found this. Keep up the good work.

    • simanaitissays
      October 31, 2016

      Thank you, Halford. As you may know, her work is regularly heard on SiriusXM Radio Classics.

  2. T.M. Fromkin
    February 22, 2023

    An addendum/correction: In addition to being named The Woman by the Baker Street Irregulars in 1987, Edith was invested in the BSI in 1991 as A Fascinating and Beautiful Woman. I was fortunate to know her in the last decade of her life, and she was indeed fascinating and beautiful.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: